Eli Manning, the former quarterback of the New York Giants, is currently a semifinalist for the Pro Football Hall of Fame Class of 2025. Despite his impressive postseason accomplishments, including two Super Bowl victories and MVP awards, there is debate among Hall of Fame voters regarding his candidacy. While many believe he will eventually be inducted, opinions vary on whether he will be a first-ballot Hall of Famer due to his regular-season record and lack of All-Pro selections.

• Eli Manning's postseason success is unmatched, with two Super Bowl MVPs.
• His regular-season record and lack of All-Pro selections raise questions about his Hall of Fame candidacy.
• Many voters believe Manning will eventually be inducted, but not necessarily on the first ballot.